A judge has officially certified a lawsuit against Apple over the controversial keyboard design for butterflies that plagued the MacBook series for years. As reported by The edgeThe lawsuit covers all MacBook models that have a butterfly keyboard.
The Butterfly keyboard has gained fame since the first version was introduced with the 12-inch MacBook in 2015 and came to the MacBook Pro and MacBook Air. This lawsuit was first filed in 2018, and it will now proceed as a certified class action lawsuit.
As today’s report explains, the lawsuit was certified by Judge Edward Davila on March 8 in California, but it was only sealed until late last week. Right now, the class action lawsuit covers people who bought a MacBook with a butterfly keyboard in seven states: California, New York, Florida, Illinois, Michigan, New Jersey and Washington.
The lawsuit specifies that the affected MacBook models include the 1
The class claims that Apple knew that the butterfly’s keyboard was defective, and it even quotes internal communications between Apple executives saying that “no matter how much lipstick you try to put on this pig, it’s still ugly,” referring to the butterfly’s keyboard. .
Apple had argued that this lawsuit should be certified as a class action lawsuit because it covers several different variants of the butterfly’s keyboard design. The plaintiffs were ultimately successful in their argument that the same basic design problems affect all variations of the butterfly’s keyboard design:
“None of the design differences that Apple points to changed the narrow spaces between the keys, nor the design with low travel,” the order states. Apple will later, in court, argue that these basic features did not actually make the design unreliable – and that it did not take many years to deliberately make defective keyboards.
The law firm behind the suit invites everyone from across the United States to participate in the class, even though they are not yet applying for nationwide certification for the lawsuit.
FTC: We automatically use affiliate links for revenue. More.
Check out 9to5Mac on YouTube for more Apple news: